World Photography Forum

World Photography Forum (https://www.worldphotographyforum.com/index.php)
-   The Photography Forum (https://www.worldphotographyforum.com/forumdisplay.php?f=21)
-   -   Canon or Nikon can you tell (https://www.worldphotographyforum.com/showthread.php?t=999)

robski 23-04-06 00:27

Well if the file name is a big clue it must be Lucca -Tuscany - Italy.

The only trade name in the file is Adobe so it is unlikely the file has come directly from a Nikon DSLR - Unless Stephen has been very crafty in hiding information embeded :rolleyes: Not even a version of Adobe ??

I'll stick my neck out and say I suspect this image has come for a scanned source.

Normally sensor shot and thermal noise is a clue to digital camera images.

Stephen 23-04-06 00:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by robski
Well if the file name is a big clue it must be Lucca -Tuscany - Italy.

The only trade name in the file is Adobe so it is unlikely the file has come directly from a Nikon DSLR - Unless Stephen has been very crafty in hiding information embeded :rolleyes: Not even a version of Adobe ??

I'll stick my neck out and say I suspect this image has come for a scanned source.

Normally sensor shot and thermal noise is a clue to digital camera images.

HaHa :D you are too clever for your own good Rob, I had forgotten about the file name though, but the exif data was stripped out in PS CS2 using Save for Web. I can't remember the last time time I scanned an image for web use though :)

robski 23-04-06 00:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen
I can't remember the last time time I scanned an image for web use though :)

Which must be a BIG hint it is digital camera :rolleyes: :D

Stephen 23-04-06 08:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by robski
Which must be a BIG hint it is digital camera :rolleyes: :D

Sorry Rob you must have missed message 10 :)

robski 23-04-06 09:22

Indeed - Also I thought it was not clear if the Canon was film or Digital. I suspect that some people could tell the difference by comparing indentical crops from original images of the scene if they know the quirks of Canon and Nikon. I can see a difference in colour and tonal range using different lens on my 20D.

When I was in the TV industry I could tell if the TV had a european or japanise CRT fitted by looking at the image colour only.

Stephen 23-04-06 09:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by robski
Indeed - Also I thought it was not clear if the Canon was film or Digital. I suspect that some people could tell the difference by comparing indentical crops from original images of the scene if they know the quirks of Canon and Nikon. I can see a difference in colour and tonal range using different lens on my 20D.

I think in the case of Canon and Nikon images, it was the silky smooth noise free tones created by the Canon CMOS sensor, whilst the Nikon seemed to be a little more contrasty and gritty. I think that now with the D200 the difference is less notable.

Quote:

Originally Posted by robski
When I was in the TV industry I could tell if the TV had a european or japanise CRT fitted by looking at the image colour only.

I can often pick out the images from Fujifilm cameras for similar reasons. The skies often are often more Cyanish than from other cameras.

On a different note, I was quite pleased that some people were more interested in the aesthetics of my photo, there is hope still :D

robski 23-04-06 09:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stephen
On a different note, I was quite pleased that some people were more interested in the aesthetics of my photo, there is hope still :D

Don't run yourself down mate, I trawled through your gallery when you joined us. Some very nice work there.

Stephen 23-04-06 10:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by robski
Don't run yourself down mate, I trawled through your gallery when you joined us. Some very nice work there.

HeHe, there is always much lost in the written word Rob :D

I was meaning hope for some of the 'techno babble' folk here. :D No offence intended guys.

robski 23-04-06 10:29

I think we all appreciate an aesthetic shot. Sometimes it getting the local materials to work with is the problem.

Canis Vulpes 23-04-06 11:04

I simply cannot tell so I need more information to be certain. Stephen Anstey's website informs me he has been using Nikon and Canon gear but more recently Canon. I am going to pin my answer on Nikon as in post 1 it was taken a few years back. I assume Stephen switched to Canon for the 20D and now 1DSMkIIn and I think the photo predates this move.

I wonder if I am correct :)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:27.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.