O.K. I'll end this one now (the thread will be locked afterwards and we do not expect other threads on this specific matter)
No one is going to be 'bounced off'. The member in question (and maybe others) have received a clear message from a large number of members about style of critique... I think it is fair to give certain parties an opportunity to change their approach to critique, especially as this is a particularly friendly community and may differ from harsher enviroments elsewhere on the web.
This has always been a friendly and laid-back site, and we will keep it that way... but everyone is entitled to another chance, notably new members who stumble across WPF and contribute without having first judged the friendly mood of the site.
It is not compulsory to show your work before offering critique BUT those who follow this route should expect some cynicism from others.
Thanks,
Andy
edit: unfortunately Bruce failed take his chance
|