LOL - John your starting to sound like a committee meeting yourself.
I think the issue is more to do with the degree of controversy. Accepting you can't please all the people all the time you can at least attempt to get a High level of agreement in the choice of PoTW. In my case the level of agreement is 3 out of 8.
If after a straw poll 80% of the people are 80% in agreement with the choice of PoTW then I'll go quietly back into my corner and view the PoTW as another worthless exercise.
PS - I would put your Saltaire Chapel in my top 3 for this week, but having said that it no doubt has given it the kiss of death.
